Friday, August 1, 2008

Politics that roots deep

Edit Post: With whatever intention the article was written, and whatever it meant to convey, has been explained by me in the second comment. I don't want anyone to misinterpret what i have written.

Family, in this post doesn’t represent my father, mother or brother. It is the whole big, fat and huge collection of Uncles and Aunties. In short, family members from both sides. Both, paternal and maternal.

The most frequent question I’m being hounded by my family members these days is, ‘ Tanu! Tum to India aaoge nai ab?’ now, I don’t have any problems whatsoever with this question, but with the pure malicious intent it is thrown at me. It is extremely irritating. Family is a good thing to have, and that too with such a big family as mine who ‘assume’ are pretty well connected with each other. So what they bitch at their own relatives back, so what if they smile at you and leave no chance of passing tones of sarcasm, so what if any achievement of some one else’s son becomes a bone of contention for them, but they fake it so well. One moment they bitxh about another relative and next moment they meet as if they are lost sisters meeting again after centuries. Any amount of achievement meets their scrutiny,

‘ Arre xyz ka ladka? Haan Haan uska to admission donation se hua hai’ ,
‘ Abc ko to boards me sirf 85% hi aaya hai’.
‘ Accha college kya hai? Bahut mahenga hai, wahan to bas paisa waala log padhta hai’,

'Dekho ABC kaise poore parivaar ka naam hansaya hai. Love marriage kiya na. Punjabi hai ladki, pata hai aapko? Inter Caste’

These are some of the comments you can easily hear (or overhear) by some of the family members whose sole purpose of life is to bitch, bitch, bitch. I mean even after their own relatives. Bloody family politics and back biting is their favorite game and their favorite venue is Shaadis, any festival where the family get together happens or even generally. When they meet anyone after a long time. Who needs a reason to bitxh? I’m not saying they bitch about me or something. And even if they bitch, I xare two hoots. They bitxh, is the thing that bothers me. I mean what kind of a family we are trying to build? No. correct that. What kind of family THEY are trying to build? And most importantly, they sometimes criticize about other family members in front of their children thus, prejudicing their children’s mind also.

So, coming back to me going to Um-rika, that is the best way they would pronounce it. The most common and famous question being asked as aforementioned is Are you going to settle there? And it irritates me. They say, ‘tumko to kabhi bihar aur India se lagaav shuru se nai raha hai.’ Now, since even I have to fake that I respect them, I keep quite. I can answer it now. Yes, I don’t have much attachment with Bihar, any would be a wrong word. Because, first of all I hate the stereotyped Biharis. I hate them from the core of my heart. Having said that, my father, my brother doesn’t fall into that category and thankfully I have not grown under that upbringing. I don’t know why, but I don’t xonnext with that kind of a mentality somehow. It is difficult for me. I may be writing shit right now. Whatever. These Biharis have a fixed and a very narrow mindset and I hate them for that. I hate them for not being able to speak English that fluently (Yes. It is a MAJOR factor, inspired by Agastya Sen or whatevr you may wish to think), they are still like 150 years behind, speaking and following a goddamn rudimentary set of beliefs, still besotted with IIT, Medixal, Brahmin-Brahmin marriages, My-Son-gets-more-salary than yours mentality and I hate it. I am urban, I don’t bitxh about anyone in the family (at least people who I love really),I am English and I want to hang around with people who harbor the similar mentality. Now, this doesn’t mean that I don’t like anyone in the family. Infaxt, it is incorrect, I simply adore some of the people of my family. I love them. I respect them. That is what respect is all about. It should come from within. Respect is not about grabbing any elder’s feet and ‘Pranam’ing thme. That is pure bullshit. Real respect and love comes from inside. There is a certain kind of connection with certain people. And with certain people there si not, no matter how good/bad they are or appear to be.

Coming again to answer those kinds of people, whatever attachment I have from my country is difficult for them to understand. Not, difficult. Impossible. So just leave it at that. Sometimes, this politics and bitxhing of people make you really sick and sometimes I want to run away from it. That is why; I think people who are settled abroad are the luckiest. Because, they are oblivious from the muddy slingshots of the so called ‘Happy Family’ whine. And I have always felt that life is so smooth away from the eyes of those ‘prying cynics’ who are reverently referred to as ‘Relatives’.

5 comments:

Rajeev said...

you know what, it hurt... not the things which you said about us Biharis, but the way you think. you reiterated what the world says,'every bihari is a chutiya.you of course are an exception.'
i have spent all but 1 year of my life in bihar... and i can very confidentaly say that Biharis are as good or as bad as any other Indian...how are you different then Raj Thackrey when you say just because some1 is a bihari, he has these particular traits? stereotyping people is so easy...bihari dehati, sardar bewakoof, chinki loose character, gujarati not-so-male, delhi/mumbai ke hue to supercool...aur south indians to khair south indians hi hain.
how can u hate some1 for not being able to speak english fluently? you may not make friends with the bihari yokels because you are 'urban'now and presumably speak very fluent english...but you hate them for this?how many indians speak fluent english?

and how did u come to the conclusion that only biharis are besotted with IIT, medical, brahmin-brahmin marriage?u have so little knowledge about your country. how many biharis do you know anyway?the one you know, u have put them under exception and your opinion about the rest is only driven by their Hindi and English.

I was hurt because i am a Bihari by heart( and if you think that makes me love my country less, you are mistaken) and i want India to shed its stereotypical view of Bihar...everything that you said are true...we dont know hindi or english, we are rustic...but should these be the reasons enough to hate us? what about your love for India? is it India minus Bihar or india-biharis?

And please excuse my english...after all I am a Bihari, and not the exceptional one.

tanul thakur said...

@ Rajeev: First things first. You got some points of my post wrong. I am laughing myself silly because I did not think you would take every word written in the post at its face value. You know people get to carried away while they write when they are upset and deviate from the main point a bit. I did that.

This post was written in context to the bitching that goes around in the family and it makes me sad because these are people you love and you want them to change, and this angers me and I said I don't like their attitude( you know regarding what) and I went to the extent of saying that I hate them. I don't hate them, I care about them and their attitude upsets me. Now, this was about some of the people close to me.

Now, lets get to people in general( people of my age group). These two years in Manipal, I have interacted with a people from a number of states(almost every state). And it was a nice change, when you get to know these people and the kind of family and society they come from, you learn a lot. And whatever I figured out, I learnt that IIT/Medical, Same Caste marriages and whatever other small things that are blown out of unimaginable proportions back here, doesn't happen there. Okay, now may be those people were an exception and you may have encountered different sets of people from the different parts of country, so there is no way you or me can say that we know our country that well. Infact, no one can. And that is the beauty of this country.

Let me come to the 'English' point. Let me again explain myself. Every one has a write to choose his/her set of people. People they would like to hang around and talk with. People who are easy to relate to. When I wrote that, I hate Biharis from the core of my heart because they can't speak English well, was incorrect. Infact, it was an incorrect thing to write( may be even ridiculous). I was very upset and misrepresnted my emotions( the kind of thing I wrote in the first paragraph, as in my 'this' comment). I just wanted to say that, there are some people with whom you get along and there are some you don't. Now, if there are some people who I don't get along with that well, does it mean that I hate them? Absolutely not. So, I was incorrect when I wrote that I hate them. I just leave those people as it is whom I don't connect with and I have no hard feelings. It is as simple as that. But, you know what, having interacted with a host of peole these two years you kind of know your frequency, that with whom kinds of you will tick along. And for me, genereally, those people are 'English'. I like English people. You may think that it to be a very shallow factor, but I don't think so. It is not always, but I enjoy more with 'English' people.Having said that, some of my best friends in Manipal were not quite 'English', but, that didn't stop me from getting along with them. These people are my lifeline. And they don't have a very high TOEFL/SAT score to boast of. So, it is just a criteria, not a thumb rule. it can't be. Never. I don't think that is a wrong thing, and me liking/getting along with 'English' people doesn't mean that I have a right to hate 'Biharis'. I dare not. So, that was a rubbish thing to write. I know many people who are far, far English and are Biharis. You are a Bihari and not an exception. But, having interacted with lots of people in college and genereally also, I have found that I don't get along that well with many Biharis, not because they don't speak English well, but the mentaility some how doesn't resonates. They refuse to leave the Bihar out of them. For that matter, anyone for me is difficult to get along with who refuse to let their own state out of their system. Be it goddamn any state. I don't stereotype people from any state. But, the attitude of some people of our state( of which the post is about) irritates me and you misunderstood me.

I agree that Biharis are as good/bad as any other Indians. But, I want them to change. I want them to change for good. A speck of dust in Dhanbad/Darbhanga worries me more than piles of garbage in Delhi or Chennai. Because all said and done i know they all are part of India, but there is something about your state that your heart pines for. And my heart still pines for Bihar and I want its people's attitude to change( because atleast from what I've observed their counterparts from other states are quite forward looking, and it has nothing to do with their proficiency in English).

Dude, thats not what I wanted to say in the post actually. The post was about something else. But, you were hurt by the way I 'think', and I just wanted to clarify that I don't think the way you think I think. I was really disturbed by what you wrote. And thought this would be the best way to sort out all confusion.

Do tell me if there is anything else lingering in your mind and we can have a healthy discussion.

:)

Rajeev said...

@tanul...yes, now this clarification was needed. i knew u somewhere got mixed up between the bitching relatives( i agree with everything u said abt them. even i have had to listen to such craps, and i think almost every indian guy has to listen to the endless rantings of padosis, chachas and chachis... except of course those who live in cities are completely cut off from everyone... which may seem better, but its not prevalent) and the Biharis. How would i have known that u didn't mean it when u said "I hate them for not being able to speak English that fluently" and ur similar outbursts??
Even i don't have many Bihari friends(though that has nothing to do with their English) and i never said that you should befriend them... u of course are absolutely free to choose friends of your type...

I still do not agree that Biharis have any more or less backward mindset then the rest of the country...

to tell u the truth i was afraid how u would react to my comment... now i'm cool:)

Guddo's corner said...

Should I call you Tannu ???? the same little boy who used be on my lap(as a Baby) while preaparing for my degree exams or Tanul Thakur ,who came with all sort of achievements and going to achieve many more in his life ......
But wahtever it may , life is like that and people are like that whether you are in Bihar , U.P ,Kashmir or Kanyakumari or even USA , anywhere in the world ?????? And God make those small , little wonderful people with different attitude , characters and sentiments for creating the WORLD !!!!!!

Yet to know many things,understand and feel, but I have little diffrent opinion and views about it, being BIHARI.....keep it up !!!!

You would learn, understand too during the course of time....

tanul thakur said...

@ Binny Mausi: You may not agree with my version of a Bihari( which was a very caricatured, cynical and stereotyped version), and that is perfectly Okay. Different people have different opinions, that makes interesting conversations. Wouldn't world be a boring place had we all agree with each other on each and everything?Cheers!!